>>49070Here is the evidence in favor of Out-of-Armenia:
1) We have many Bronze Age Anatolian samples, and few to none of them have any significant amount of Steppe ancestry
2) Anatolian split off the earliest out of all the Indo-European languages, implying that the "splitting" point was not in Europe but below or in the Caucasus.
3) According to the Southern Arc papers, Yamnaya have a very slight "Anatolia-Levantine" input and elevated CHG DNA, which may imply some sort of migration from Chalcolithic Armenia. They claim that this cannot come from European EEFs, as it doesn't have a WHG element to it
However, there are many problems with this theory.
1) While we have many Anatolian Bronze Age samples, we have only a few from Western Anatolia and none of high quality from Northwest Anatolia. This is where the Indo-Anatolian intrusion was expected to have happened under Steppe hypothesis, and so this would be where the Steppe DNA would be most potent.
2) While our Anatolian samples don't have sizeable amounts of Steppe (A few seem to actually have a very slight Steppe pull, in the single digits) this does not prove that the languages did not come from Steppe invaders. Remember that this was likely before the Indo-Europeans had wagons or chariots, and they probably weren't riding horses into battle either. The Anatolians also spent a great deal of time in the Balkans, as the Suvorovo, Varna, and Cernavodă cultures most likely. So it is likely they were already heavily diluted before ever stepping foot in Asia Minor. Meanwhile, Asia Minor was already rather densely populated for Chalcolithic standards, even having cities. So it is fairly easy to assume that the Indo-Europeans became a tiny ruling elite, like the Magyars or Avars in Hungary.
3) Prior studies seem to disagree with the claim that Yamnaya don't have any WHG ancestry, and they have usually been modeled with some WHG pull, so it is rather odd that the Southern Arc studies did not find this. An interesting blog post by an Indian like yourself makes a compelling argument for why A) Yamnaya actually DID have input from local Farmers (ex: Cuceteni-Tripolye, Globular Amphora) and B) The supposed "Levantine pull" in Yamnaya already existed from Eneolithic samples in Southern Russia.
https://vicayana.substack.com/p/southern-arc-or-southern-farceHowever, is it even necessary for Yamnaya to have WHG DNA? I think not. While yes, the most proximal Cuceteni-Tripolye farmers did have WHG ancestry, farmers in the Balkans such as the Vinca culture were still essentially pure Anatolians. It could very easily have come from a bit further south. The Levantine ancestry they find is very little, like 3% iirc, so I would consider it probably just an artifact of very ancient Levantine mixture into Anatolians. (This is what the Southern Arc study says as well, saying Anatolians and Levantines formed a cline)
4) While Yamnaya has far more CHG-like ancestry than Khvalynsk or Ukraine_Meso, it has significantly less than that of the aforementioned samples from Southern Russia (Progress_En). Yamnaya can be perfectly modeled as a combination of Progress, Khvalynsk, Ukraine_N, and EEF. No need to go south of the border.
5) The primary haplogroups we see in Yamnaya and Corded Ware are not Middle Eastern. They all have their closest ancestral relatives in Eastern Europe and are likely EHG-descended. Considering that these cultures were patrilineal, patrilocal, and patriarchal, it doesn't really make sense for them to adopt languages of foreign clans. Definitely not entire cultures. However, in all fairness, some Indo-European cultures seemed to retain the Y-DNA of their autochthonous ancestors rather than their Indo-European ancestors.
6) Linguists seem to primarily agree with the Steppe Urheimat hypothesis still, on the grounds that the Anatolian languages seemed to disperse from west to east, rather than from east to west. I believe there are also some arguments from environmental vocabulary, but I'm not all that familiar. Basically, the most "basal" Anatolian languages are the ones in western Anatolia, implying they came in that way and out the back. This doesn't line up with Anatolian coming from the Armenian Plateau. Many archaeologists also stress relationships between the Cernavoda culture and Anatolians, meanwhile there is no archaeological culture which went from below or within the Caucasus into the Steppe during that time.
7) There are some leaked Sredni Stog samples (basically the Steppe Urheimat "Homeland" culture) which appear to be very Yamnaya-like. If these cultures are genetically continuous with Yamnaya, then the date of this supposed "extra admixture" in Yamnaya would have to be pushed back to before the Anatolian languages split off, which would make all the evidence from Anatolia rather irrelevant.