Once, Carleton Coon said that the people who immigrate from their birthplace to another tend to be different than the peoples from whence they came from (e.g. Polish-Americans being blonder, more Nordic overall than the average Poles).
Therefore, the same could be said for Spain. I noticed a pattern where the Criollo or even, Castizo Hispanicamericans look more typically Western European than your average Peninsular Spaniard.
The Spaniard of Atlantid/Nordid stock was more adventorous and better suited for conquest. The limited Spaniard with Semitic, Hamitic and Sudanid influences in their genome couldn't actually commit and stayed.