>>18977722I think you are conflating several different claims here, and I have to separate them to address it.
Christianity does not teach aversion to the real world. It teaches aversion to sin and disordered attachment to worldly goods. That is entirely different. The Incarnation itself is almost the exact inversion of the idea that matter or earthly existence is something wrong. Christianity fundamentally rejects that idea. The Christian claim that the Word truly became flesh, possessing real human nature. Catholic theology rightfully rejects the old Gnostic idea that matter is inherently evil. The Incarnation is central to that worldview, that matter is redeemed and fundamentally elevated to a higher Good.
Likewise, when our Lord Jesus Christ said, "My kingdom is not of this world," this does not mean "My kingdom has nothing to do with this world." It means that Christ's kingdom does not originate from a political order or depend on worldly forces. Christianity distinguishes the supernatural end of man from the temporal ends of civil society. The old Catholic doctrine explicitly recognizes the state as a genuine natural institution with authority over temporal secular affairs, rather than regarding political life as intrinsically illegitimate.
That distinction is actually present clearly in Saint Augustine's The City of God. He does not argue that Christians should abolish the earthly governments or civilization. He explicitly said that the earthly peace and the goods associated with it are genuine goods, although inferior to the eternal good.
Furthermore, the idea that Christianity became successful by simply copying the Roman method of conquest reverses historical sequence. Christianity spent three centuries as a persecuted religion before it even received imperial toleration and eventually as a state religion of the Roman Empire. The Catholic historical account is quite explicit that the Roman government first attempted to suppress Christianity. Even secular sources say this. And that persecution eventually failed. Constantine's toleration was not a humiliation of Christian military conquest at Rome.
Yes, indeed, Christian emperors and rulers certainly exercised coercive political power, and Christian rulers sometimes committed grave injustices, but this does not establish that the Church conquered Europe by military force. Distinction matters. The Catholic Encyclopedia, for example, openly acknowledged forced conversions under rulers such as Charlemagne, but simultaneously states that the Church's principle was that conversion must be free, and the Church repeatedly opposed forced baptism. This means that when us Christians are going to convert peoples, if they adamantly refuse, they refuse. You do not force them. If they do not want the message of Christ and refuse so, then go ahead, respect their decision. Go on with other pagans who are more willing to be open to the Christian message. And just hope and pray that those pagans who reject Christianity will accept it eventually.